You’re in the car after the show, voice gone, scrolling for the setlist so you can relive every song in order. Here’s the honest catch: there isn’t one Noah Kahan Stick Season tour setlist. The order shifted between stops, acoustic moments moved, guests appeared on specific nights, and by 2024 the Fenway shows ran under a different tour name entirely. So instead of a mashed-together “definitive” list, this guide lays out the documented sets by venue and exact date, explains what stayed constant, and shows how fans are turning a single night into something they can actually wear.
- No single setlist covers every Stick Season show; song order and selections varied by night.
- The documented September 2, 2023 Saratoga set ran 17 songs, opening with Northern Attitude and closing with Homesick.
- Stick Season was usually the encore centerpiece, but at Saratoga it was the second-to-last song, not the closer.
- The July 2024 Fenway shows were billed as the We'll All Be Here Forever tour, and the two nights had different setlists.
- Always label a setlist by venue and date before using it for a keepsake or gift.
Saratoga, September 2, 2023: a documented Stick Season set
The clearest documented 2023 Stick Season Tour setlist comes from Saratoga Performing Arts Center on September 2, 2023: 14 main-set songs from Northern Attitude to Dial Drunk, then an encore of The View Between Villages, Stick Season and Homesick. It’s one real night, not a template for every stop.
Per Holler (2023), the Saratoga show ran 17 songs, with Growing Sideways and Paul Revere performed acoustic.
- Northern Attitude
- She Calls Me Back
- New Perspective
- Everywhere, Everything
- Your Needs, My Needs
- Maine
- Growing Sideways (acoustic)
- Paul Revere (acoustic)
- All My Love
- False Confidence
- Call Your Mom
- You’re Gonna Go Far
- Orange Juice
- Dial Drunk
- Encore: The View Between Villages
- Encore: Stick Season
- Encore: Homesick
Many fans assume Stick Season ended the night. At Saratoga it was the penultimate song; Homesick closed the concert, according to Holler (2023).
Why your show's order probably looked different
Song order varied during the Stick Season era. The Austin City Limits taping on September 25, 2023 opened with All My Love instead of Northern Attitude, while keeping the same three-song encore.
The Austin City Limits recap (2023) shows the shuffle clearly. One caveat: that was a television taping, so treat it as evidence that order moved around, not as a standard tour stop.
| Detail | Saratoga (Sept 2, 2023) | ACL taping (Sept 25, 2023) |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Tour concert | TV taping |
| Opener | Northern Attitude | All My Love |
| Encore | The View Between Villages, Stick Season, Homesick | The View Between Villages, Stick Season, Homesick |
| Final song | Homesick | Homesick |
Two documented September 2023 performances
The pattern worth remembering: openers and mid-set placement moved, but that encore trio held steady across both documented 2023 performances.
Fenway 2024 was a different tour with two different nights
The July 2024 Fenway Park concerts were billed as the We’ll All Be Here Forever tour, not the 2023 Stick Season Tour. The July 18 show had a 23-song set opening with Dial Drunk and ending with Mess, The View Between Villages and Stick Season.
Boston.com (2024) documented that even back-to-back Fenway nights didn’t match. That’s exactly why a reliable setlist needs a date attached.
| Detail | July 18, 2024 | July 19, 2024 |
|---|---|---|
| Songs unique to the night | Pain Is Cold Water, The Great Divide, No Complaints | Come Over, Call Your Mom, Young Blood |
| Guests | Gracie Abrams on Everywhere, Everything; The Lumineers on If We Were Vampires (Jason Isbell cover) | Mt. Joy members on Northern Attitude; Kahan's family on the Stick Season finale |
| Encore | Mess, The View Between Villages, Stick Season | Stick Season finale with family |
Fenway Park, July 18 vs. July 19, 2024
Boston.com also posted video of the family finale (2024) if you were at the July 19 show and want to see it again.
At Fenway on July 18, 2024, Kahan wore a baseball-style uniform with NK stitched on the front and Forever on the back.— Boston.com (2024)
Turning your setlist into something you'll wear
The best concert keepsake ties to your actual night: the venue, the date, or the song that hit hardest. Kahan’s own stitched NK and Forever uniform at Fenway is a good reminder that embroidery is the right medium for this.
I’ve stitched plenty of concert pieces, and the ones people keep reaching for are quiet. A small chest motif, a song title in serif lettering, maybe a date on the sleeve. Before you order, confirm your exact setlist using the dated sources above so you don’t embroider a song you didn’t actually hear. If you want the wider picture of what’s out there, our stick season merch roundup compares styles.
A fit for Fenway-goers, echoing the Forever stitched on Kahan's jersey.
A forest road-trip design for fans who heard The Great Divide on July 18.
A cabin motif that suits the encore-closing Stick Season moment, and an easy gift.
Saratoga 2023 fans might lean on Homesick, the closer. Fenway 2024 fans have the Forever theme. Want the song meanings behind your pick? Read our Stick Season lyrics breakdown.
Quick questions
Did Noah Kahan always close with Stick Season?
No. At Saratoga on September 2, 2023, Homesick closed the show and Stick Season came second-to-last. At Fenway on July 18, 2024, Stick Season ended the encore.
How many songs were in the Stick Season tour setlist?
It varied. The documented Saratoga 2023 show had 17 songs, while the July 18, 2024 Fenway show, under the We'll All Be Here Forever tour, had 23.
Who were the guests at Noah Kahan's Fenway shows?
On July 18, 2024, Gracie Abrams and The Lumineers joined. On July 19, Mt. Joy members joined Northern Attitude and Kahan's family joined the Stick Season finale.
